Tuesday, September 16th, 2008...1:25 pm
The poor, minorities pay with their lives
Time and time again, research has shown that the poor and minorities come up on the short end of the longevity stick.
Some of the blame can be placed on inactivity and dietary choices.
But a four-part PBS documentary, Unnatural Causes: Is Inequality Making Us Sick, which first aired in March, shows mounting evidence that sometimes economic status, race and environment can be better predictors of health than our own poor choices.
The documentary demonstrated how at each economic level — rich to middle class to poor — health declines at the same rate as our money.
In two weeks, on Oct. 1, Dr. Adewale Troutman, executive director of the Louisville Metro Health Department, will lead a community forum in Lexington at which those indicators and others will be discussed.
Troutman, featured in part one of the PBS film, collaborated with former U.S. Surgeon General David Satcher on a 2005 paper — “What If We Were Equal? A Comparison of the Black-White Mortality Gap in 1960 and 2000″ — that also concluded health inequalities exist along racial and economic lines.
According to the PBS documentary, as inequality grows and as the number of children living in poverty increases, the life expectancy for the richest country on Earth continues to decline. In 1980, we ranked 14th worldwide in life expectancy. In 2007, we were 29th.
That is not all lousy eating habits and exercise avoidance. Other factors include stress and all the tangents associated with poverty, such as under-education, under-employment and being overlooked by our health care system.
For the PBS documentary, filmmakers went to Louisville to explore patterns of illness, race and socioeconomic status.
Troutman said the health community talks about eating more fruits and vegetables, but what if you live in an area in which fresh foods are rare?
“We have one in the west end of Louisville,” he said. “You find them in poor communities.”
Then, good health is not a personal choice, he said, but is reliant on “structural and systemic factors.”
Those factors include a deficient education, unemployment and violence.
Troutman said a 10-year difference in life expectancy can be found between one council district and another in Louisville.
It is time to look upstream for causes instead of simply treating resulting diseases such as diabetes, high blood pressure, cancer and heart disease, he said.
Government agencies and leaders in Louisville have recognized the need to change perspective, Troutman said.
In 2006, Louisville opened the Center for Health Equity, created by Mayor Jerry Abramson to eliminate health inequities based on race, ethnicity or socioeconomic status. The center is a collaboration among community members, local government, private business and health care organizations.
“Dr. Troutman is really trying to focus on the root causes of why minorities and the poor are sicker in our society,” said Camille Watson, health educator at the Lexington-Fayette County Health Department, one of the forum sponsors. “Getting people healthier is the end result.”
If you go
Community forum featuring Dr. Adewale Troutman
When: 6 to 8 p.m. Oct. 1.
Where: Kentucky Education Television Center, 600 Cooper Dr.
Cost: Free, but reservations are encouraged.
Contact: Camille Watson at (859) 288-2332 or CamilleA.Watson@ky.gov


I am a native Kentuckian, and I have worked at the Lexington Herald-Leader for nearly a quarter of a century. I've been a columnist for almost 20 of those years, dispensing my opinions about anything and everything. Born in Owensboro, Ky., I'm old enough to have lived through racial segregation, the Civil Rights Movement, protests against the Vietnam War, and the break-up of the Beatles. That means I am "old school," and my thoughts emanate from that perspective.
2 Comments
September 16th, 2008 at 9:46 pm
Merlene,
If people of “lesser status”? want better health, stop eating ham bones, and kale…….stop eating chittlins, and fatback, stop treating your body as if it were a garbage dump. Stop smoking crack, meth, krank, and every other bit of ignorance they can think of putting into their bodies.
Your life is what you make it, everyone is born with the same suit of clothes and we all go out in the same.
Society is not the monster in the machine, idiots like you who want society to be the all seeing evil are.
Semper Fi
September 18th, 2008 at 8:08 pm
The adult obesity rate in 1980 was 15%; now it is around 34%. This coupled this with the fact that obese people tend to have poor eating habits (high fat foods instead of healthy foods) as well as a lack of exercise regimen would do more to explain our decline of life expectancy, than your supposition “as inequality grows.”
To the extent that they can, individuals need to take responsibility for their health. This is even more important for someone with limited access to health care. While it may be popular or politically correct to blame “stress” and “other tangents” for bad health, diet, exercise, and lifestyle (not smoking) play a bigger role. If you’re not taking care of those first, then it’s irresponsible to try to blame other factors.
P.S. While the number of children living in poverty (somewhat of a misnomer in the US compared to the 3rd world) in the US has increased since 1980 (as has the total population), the poverty RATE has essentially remained the same.
Leave a Reply